The Indianapolis Star: Website Evaluation

By: Alyson Svec

The Indianapolis Star, which can be accessed online at indystar.com, joined with the Gannett Company to provide users easy access to content about important issues, up to date news, sports, entertainment, weather, and even obituaries. Multimedia is used throughout the site, with links to different sections and stories, as well as photos, icons, a weather widget and even a countdown to the Indianapolis Super Bowl this year. The website provides ways to contact the organization by using social media sites such as Facebook or Twitter. There are helpful tabs including, Top News, Most Popular or News For You, so the user can decide what to view. An organized design is used, and the information is grouped separately to view important information easier. The website actively keeps up with current events going on in the world today.

Photo by IndyStar.com

A recent article I read here, explained how former Survivor star, Rubert Boneham is running for a government position for Indiana. It provides good use of media by including text, using photos and allowing users to comment on the article. Links are also included to provide more information about related topics in Indiana, Boneham’s personal website, and important people associated with his campaign to give the users a more interactive experience. At the end of the article, there is a ‘You Might Be Interested In’ section which includes video and clickable story links to further your interest with a related topic.

The Indianapolis Star is visually appealing. The name of the website alone caught my interest. Besides media, there are feature sections, classifieds, archives and more. Large advertisements consume the right side of the page, but the site still grabs my attention and interest for wanting to read, search or view more.

The site has countless possibilities and covers a wide range of topics. Overall, this is an accurate, reliable and professional looking site to rely on for information and news.

TexasMonthly.com keeps things simple, uninteresting

The TexasMonthly.com website should include a variety of multimedia content that would help add visual appeal and promote overall interest in the site. However, the site lacks multimedia and visuals and the stories usually contain only a photo or two, and usually come across as uninteresting or downright boring. The homepage itself uses a relatively simple design template of a white and gray background, with an ever-changing featured story located prominently near the top left of the page, just under the publication’s name. A photo slide show is used to help grab and hold the reader’s attention and its location near the top left of the page makes the slide show one of the first things visitors to the site will see.  Directly to the right of the slide show, where readers’ eyes should be expected to move after passing over the slide show, is a link allowing visitors to subscribe to the physical magazine. The site is produced by Texas Monthly magazine, a publication owned by Emmis Publishing, and since it supports a monthly magazine the information on the site isn’t updated as often as would be expected of the content of a news website. The site’s content is catered to Texans, and as such contains many articles about statewide travel, food and wine tastings and state politics, but has little to no information about events occurring outside the state.

Because Mack Brown has Something to Prove

One of the featured stories on the TexasMonthly.com website is an interview with Texas Longhorns coach Mack Brown. The story is two pages long, but contains only one small illustration (yes, illustration, not photo) of a fierce-looking Brown at the top of the first page. The story is written in question and answer format and does not use photos or video, which would have greatly added to the visual appeal of the article. There is a Facebook comment box near the story’s headline which allows readers to share their comments directly from the page and there are also links to share the story with other social media sites. Advertisements and contest notices clutter both sides of the page, and draw attention away from the story since they are the only items on the page that feature color or animation. The story itself reads basically like a biography of the coach, and I have serious doubts that anyone but a die-hard UT fan would read the story in its entirety without more visuals and multimedia content.

Website evaluation: San Antonio Express-News

By: Selina Smith

The San Antonio Express-News or mysanantonio.com, produced by Hearst Communications Inc., continues to slowly build its multimedia content. The website is insightful in giving the readers the news and goes in hand with its printed newspaper to develop a professional journalistic outlook on San Antonio. The site’s information is primarily local based, with little national based news. The format is clear and precise, capturing the readers interest. The breaking news is on the front page and stories are placed in the section that suits the article best (Business, News, Sports, etc.). Whether its politics in Texas, crimes committed in San Antonio or sports, this frequently updated website provides all types of news in the local community. 

The site relies on words and/or pictures to tell the story.  Although the website uses some multimedia content, from photos to reader participation, videos seem uncommon and pictures at times don’t convey the impact of the stories. A recent article involving the concept of VIA Metropolitan Transit streetcars in downtown San Antonio has been a long debate in the city. Though the article gives a detailed struggle to bring VIA streetcars to San Antonio, including a comments section for people to voice their opinions, the story ultimately feels plain. The article is three pages, with no pictures or video links and comes off long and  at times dull. There are no visuals or pictures to capture the readers’ attention to let them know that the topic is a major development in the San Antonio community.

The use of different mediums, such as visuals, in some way could’ve impacted the long struggle for VIA streetcars.  Interviews from city and county officials giving their opinions regarding the issue could put some perspective on how much conflict there is regarding the issue. Also, interviews from the locals on how they feel about streetcars downtown would make the article livelier.

San Antonio Express-News has a long way to go to have the complete “multimedia package”, but what they do have is a start. The homepage is an example of what mediums the San Antonio Express-News can overall bring to their website. If journalists can bring the mediums that are on the homepage to their own stories, then readers will be introduced to a new outlook of multimedia journalism.

Chris Eudaily – ESPN

Overall site evaluation: ESPN.go.com

The element that stands out when the ESPN homepage loads on your browser is the Top Stories window that features several of the most interesting stories of the day, all with a large graphic big enough to dominate the space on the page and all ready for you to click on. Each of these usually has a video, which will play straight from the homepage without taking you away from the homepage content. As you continue to look around there are a lot of pictures, and the site seems to always have a current poll about the latest sports news. There are always a couple quick video links, and as you scroll down each page you will find quick links to associated podcasts as well.  ESPN does a great job of having a picture next to almost every single story, which grabs your attention more than a simple text headline and also helps you to get a better picture of what each story will be about. The majority of video and graphic content comes as you navigate into specific stories and shows. ESPN’s video series Outside the Lines, 30 for 30 and E:60 have vast amounts of video content complete with archives of old stories.

ESPN has done a great job of putting together complete story packages. There will often be a featured video at the top of a story, which is either a feature video package or the clip from Sportscenter, accompanied by a written portion, links to associated articles, and sometimes charts or other graphics which help to flesh-out the story.  This allows you to learn a great deal about a story and then find out what else has happened with this topic without having to comb through the entire website.

It is easy to tell who wrote the stories and who put together the video packages as credits are clearly presented on each element. I’m sure that the web developers and editors at ESPN have spent a great deal of time refining the best way to get a cohesive look to the presentation of stories on their website; this doesn’t just happen by accident. The presentation of each story on the web is consistent and well organized so that each multimedia element is able to work with each other to accentuate the reader’s experience, rather than competing with each other for a reader’s attention.
Specific story with multimedia elements or multimedia project – A Man Obsessed

http://espn.go.com/espn/eticket/worldtriathlon

Charlie Wittmack is married, has a little boy and  looks like a normal middle aged man living in the suburbs. Charlie Wittmack is also an adventurer, and has a primal urge to push his body to the extreme, which led him to come up with the toughest triathlon known to man: The World Triathlon. This grueling trek includes a 250 mile swim which includes swimming the English Channel, a 9,000 mile bike ride polished off with a 750 mile run/climb to the top of Mount Everest.  This story chronicles Charlie’s struggles with money, injuries, his relationship with his family, and the mental torment of the triathlon itself.

Multimedia is vital to the telling of this story because there are so many different levels in Charlie’s adventure. Everything starts with the magazine-like design of each page in the series that combine to tell the complete tale. These designs are based from pictures of Charlie’s trip and his family, which lends a simplicity to them that feels incredibly dynamic and powerful. The first page really sets the tone and gives the reader that perfect blend of the known and the unknown; you can take a look at the first page design, watch the video, and know what this story is about, but you still feel like there is plenty that you don’t know.  Several page designs flawlessly integrate maps of Charlie’s trek so that you can see his path before going further into the story.

Some sections in the story are told by video, which is perfect to capture the terrain that Charlie is covering and is also the perfect medium to relay Charlie’s emotions when the going gets tough.  Other parts of this story are told using text, which makes you as a reader have to actively read in order to continue revealing more facets.

By using several mediums to tell this story, the producers mirror the many elements happening within the story itself, and so as a reader you find yourself going on a bit of a journey in order to learn more about Charlie’s journey. It’s a great storytelling trick, and one that is made more exciting with multimedia.

I think a large interactive map of his entire journey would be a great addition, where readers could click on different plots on the line to see pictures of that moment in Charlie’s trek.  It wouldn’t be necessary, but by zooming out and showing the entire journey, you could add another perspective to the trip itself, especially if you were to show it from a satellite shot.

 

- This story was mainly featured on Outside the Lines, where they also had a discussion. It also featured in ESPN the Magazine, which covered Charlie’s wife’s perspective of the story, and you could also listen to Charlie’s “The Sporting Life” radio interview. Charlie also did a live online chat through Sports Nation, another one of ESPN’s shows.

Assignment: Evaluating Media Websites

The best way to learn about multimedia journalism is to study existing examples and evaluate their effectiveness. In some respects media outlets are quite similar, but in other respects they differ greatly.

For this assignment, select a website from the list below. So that we have no duplications, post a comment on this posting to indicate which media outlet you want to claim from the list. Once a media outlet has been selected, it is out of play. No duplications.

Refer to Foust’s Intro to Online Journalism, chapter 1 pages 13-15 “Evaluating Online Sites.” Use the questions and explanations to evaluate your assigned website.
Answer these questions:
• Who is producing the site?
• What is the content of the site?
• Is the information accurate?
• How often is the information updated?
• What does the site look like?

Answer these questions about the site in general and select a specific story to use as an example of the use (or lack of use) of multimedia.

You will post your website evaluation on this blog. Give your blog post an appropriate headline. Write brief answers to these questions. You may offer opinion. Include links to any pertinent examples. Include a screen-grab or photo. Be prepared to discuss your evaluation in class.

Media outlets to evaluate

Washingtonpost.com

NYTimes.com

CNN.com

HuffingtonPost.com

Tampa Bay Online tbo.com

WFAA.com (TV)

LasVegasSun.com

IndyStar.com

VictoriaAdvocate.com

TylerPaper.com

WTVG-TV

Texas Monthly

ESPN

Sports Illustrated

San Antonio Express-News

Austin American-Statesman

Dallas Morning News

http://claythorp.wordpress.com/

Professional Blog

http://mm1494.wordpress.com/